WE SUPPORT THEM
Representative Miller-Meeks has made further pronouncements in which she is in favor of law and order and for that reason fully supports the people employed in law enforcement who believe in keeping us safe, i. e. the police. Let me say immediately, that police and other law enforcement are necessary components of any modern society. If someone breaks into your house, you want someone to at least attempt to find out who did it. Or if you get beat up on a street corner, it would be gratifying to know the person was arrested. Technically speaking, police do not "fight crime", they punish those who commit it. There is no such thing as "fighting crime"; "crime" is what people do when they do things that have been deemed criminal by a legislature. We have currently the view that police are good and that's that - - end of analysis. This is why we, in this state, are being rid of our municipal police oversight commissions. Our legislature is of the opinion that police are good and that is the end of it. We don't need any oversight.
I, however, having practiced criminal law in this state for more years than I want to count, I say it's not so simple. One can not argue with the proposition that there are capable lawyers and those not so capable; there are capable doctors and doctors not so capable, there are real estate agents that do good work and some not so good, there are pharmacists that are excellent and those not so excellent. This is why we have established commissions or committees or bureaus, whatever you may call them, to make inquiry when they receive complaints about the services they have received from their doctor or their lawyer or their real estate agent or their pharmacist.
Representative Miller-Meeks has joined, if not a permanent member, of those who state that of all the occupations that can be thought of or exist, police are the one group of people who need no oversight. These are the people who can put you in jail; these are the people who enforce the rules one needs to follow to get to work; these are the people who cost you money in the form of bail; these are the people who when they take you to jail force you to leave behind the family, the pets, the job, etc. These are the people that can cause you damage, discomfort, loss of income, and serious inconvenience. But they are the only profession that needs no oversight apparently.
In addition, take a look at an officer or a deputy when you converse with them; take an inventory of the equipment they have on their person; take an inventory of the equipment they have in their squad car. It is as if they have prepared for battle with the Taliban. These are the people who need no oversight, but they are the one group of people who, at their fingertips, have the ability and equipment to do you serious harm.
I am not against the police and I am not against the deputies, but I do know good ones from bad ones. They both exist just as they exist in every occupation. Refusing to admit to this appears to be simply another pathetic effort to make public statements that get votes from people who have never given it a thought or who have never had an interaction with law enforcement. Every function necessary for a successful society needs oversight.
Richard E H Phelps II
Mingo